Momentous ruling by the UK High Court

UK High Court clarifies steps charities can take to align their investments with their values

  • A new High Court judgement has ruled on trustees’ ability to align their investments with their charities’ values.
  • The judgment has clarified that trustees ‘need to’ undertake a balancing exercise between maximising their returns and avoiding investments that could contradict their aims.
  • We believe that this ruling should make trustees more confident in their ability to align their investments with their charitable missions. However, we do not believe that they necessarily have to sacrifice returns to achieve this.

Should charities be able to align their investment strategies to their charitable purpose even if that means excluding many potential investments?

In a new judgement the UK's High Court has ruled that the trustees for the two charities can align their investments with their mission even if this involves financial risk by excluding a large part of the market.

The case, brought by the Ashden Trust and the Mark Leonard Trust (two of the Sainsbury Family Charitable Trusts), sought clarity on whether the charities could align their investments with the goals of the Paris Climate Change Agreement. The ruling stated that this was possible, even if it had a dramatic impact upon their portfolio, as it was reasonable to suggest that investing in companies that are not aligned with the goal to limit global temperature rises would contradict their objectives in regard to the environment and the relief of poverty.

What is the existing guidance for trustees?

The existing guidance for trustees is set out by the Charity Commission in CC14.

This states that trustees of any charity can decide to align their portfolios with their mission (referred to as ethical investing), even if the investment might provide a lower rate of return than an alternative investment. However, a charity’s trustees must be able to justify why it is in the charity’s best interests to invest in this way. The law permits the following reasons:

  • A particular investment conflicts with the aims of the charity; or
  • The charity might lose supporters or beneficiaries if it does not invest ethically; or
  • There is no significant financial detriment.

Under this guidance, trustees must ensure that any decision that they take about adopting an ethical investment approach can be justified within the criteria set out by the Charity Commission. They must be clear about the reasons why certain companies or sectors are excluded or included. Trustees should also evaluate the effect of any proposed policy on potential investment returns and balance any risk of lower returns against the risk of alienating support or damage to reputation.

This guidance is based upon ‘the Bishop of Oxford case’ which is the only reported case dealing with ‘so-called’ ethical investments by charities. It was brought by the then Bishop of Oxford (and two other priests) against the Church Commissioners in relation to their investment policy concerning South Africa. The case was heard in 1991, at the time South Africa was transitioning to democracy and there were a range of views within the Church of England about the appropriateness of investing in South Africa.

What does the new ruling mean?

This landmark ruling reinterprets the Bishop of Oxford case. Most visibly this relates to climate change which was not considered in the original case. The ruling clarifies the extent to which climate change can be considered to be in conflict to a broad range of charitable objects and thus a large number of charities can take action to align their portfolio with, or use their investments to contribute to, the goal of limiting temperature rises. On the back of this ruling, we expect that more and more charities will seek to align their investments to support climate action even if environmental protection is not explicitly stated within their charitable objectives.

However, the ruling has further implications – beyond climate change - as to how charities can align their assets with their mission. It states that ‘the power to invest must … be exercised to further the [charities’] charitable purposes’ and that whilst this ‘is normally achieved’ by maximising financial returns trustees ‘should’ avoid direct conflicts between their investments and their purpose. It goes further to state that trustees ‘need to’ exercise ‘good judgement’ by balancing this requirement against the risk of financial detriment.

We therefore believe that the ruling will create a more permissive environment for charities to put their purpose at the forefront of their investment strategy and opens the door to charities adopting increasingly ambitious investment approaches where climate change and their values are concerned.

How can charities align their portfolios with their values?

There are several ways that charities can take steps to integrate their values into their investments. These include:

  • negative screening: this means avoiding investment in companies or sectors or companies undertaking a particular activity or operating in a way which may be harmful to the charity’s interests.
  • positive screening: this means investing all or part of an investment portfolio in companies or sectors which reflect a charity’s values in areas like environmental protection, health, employment or human rights, or in a wider range of companies that demonstrate good corporate social responsibility and governance; for example, positive screening might involve only investing in companies that have targets/proven records for reducing their carbon footprint
  • stakeholder activism: this is where a charity, as a shareholder, exercises its voting rights in order to influence a company’s policies in a way that reflects its values and ethos; this could mean that a charity might invest in companies whose environmental policies it does not approve of in order to encourage more responsible business practices within those companies - it is also possible to engage in stakeholder activism as a programme related or mixed motive investment.

Each of these approaches are included in the management of CCLA’s pooled funds for charities.

Every CCLA pooled fund adopts some form of ethical restriction, designed specifically to meet the needs of the charities that invest in them. We also seek to dedicate capital to activities – such as the provision of renewable energy – that will provide a market rate return and a social and/or environmental good. Finally, we seek to be active owners of the assets that we manage; engaging and voting in a way that is designed to improve companies’ sustainability.

How should we consider climate change after this ruling?

Whilst the clarity bestowed by the new ruling will be helpful to charity trustees, we have long-seen climate change as a material financial issue for investors. If unmitigated, climate change will continue to lead to increased poverty in many low- income countries, erratic weather patterns and accelerated biodiversity loss. For instance, loss of biodiversity, natural resource crises are all listed by the World Economic Forum as key global risks, that are impacted by the physical effects of climate change, for companies and the functioning of the global economy. Because of this it is also a material threat to the functioning of investment markets and shareholder value. This is a critical issue for investors and for this reason we have long supported the effort to limit global temperatures to substantially below 2 degrees above pre-industrial levels. For this reason, we believe that investors have a fiduciary duty to push for accelerated climate action and begin to take steps to protect their portfolios from the financial risks it will cause.

As a founding member of the Net Zero Asset Managers’ initiative, CCLA has committed to seek to achieve net-zero emissions portfolios for all our assets under management no later than 2050. We therefore already help charities align their investments with positive climate action in line with the Paris Agreement. Specifically, we do this within our Act, Assess, Align framework in the following ways:

  • Act: We act to increase the pace of climate action by leading impactful engagements with the companies in which we invest and push policymakers for progressive regulation and legislation.
  • Assess: We assess companies’ position against the energy transition as part of our investment process and avoid those that do the most harm. CCLA has no direct investment in fossil fuel companies1 in carbon intensive sectors are assessed against sector specific decarbonisation requirements against decarbonisation scenarios. As part of our commitment to real-world change, any business that is not assessed as being aligned with a ‘below 2 degrees’ future is prioritised for engagement. The efficacy of this engagement is monitored by the Investment Committee who can mandate divestment if sufficient progress is not being made.
  • Align: We align our portfolios with our clients’ specific climate requirements and disclose information about our approach to managing the risks and opportunities associated with climate change.

We are therefore well equipped to continue helping charities achieve their goals whilst aligning their investments with their values including those concerning climate change.

More information about our climate approach can be found here.

 
 

 

 

1 Defined as companies that generate more than 5% of their revenue from the extraction of energy coal or tar sands or companies that generate more than 10% of their revenue from the extraction and/or refining of oil and gas

 

Important Information

This document is issued for information purposes only. It does not constitute the provision of financial, investment or other professional advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. The value of investments and the income derived from them may fall as well as rise. Investors may not get back the amount originally invested and may lose money. Any forward looking statements are based upon CCLA's current opinions, expectations and projections. Such opinions, expectations or projections may be subject to change at any time. CCLA undertakes no obligations to update or revise these. Actual results could differ materially from those anticipated.

CCLA Investment Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Terms and conditions

Website terms of use policy

CCLA Website Terms of Use

Welcome to CCLA's website for:

  • fund management services for  CCLA Funds (details of and documentation relating to all CCLA Funds is available on CCLA’s website); and
  • discretionary investment management services for individual client portfolios.

This page provides you with information about CCLA and the legal terms and conditions (Terms of Use or Terms) on which you can access and use this website.

By using or accessing any part of this website, you confirm that you accept these Terms of Use and that you agree to comply with them.  Please read these Terms of Use carefully and make sure that you understand them before using this website. If you do not wish to be bound by these Terms you must not use or access this website.

Where necessary, we may amend these Terms of Use from time to time by updating this page.  We therefore recommend that you check this page periodically to ensure that you understand the Terms which will apply from time to time.

1. About us (CCLA)

1.1 Any reference to CCLA or we/us on this website (including these Terms of Use) means CCLA Investment Management Limited and/or CCLA Fund Managers Limited (as applicable).

1.2 CCLA Investment Management Limited (CCLA IM) is a company registered in England and Wales with company number 2183088. It is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA), and is entered on the Financial Services Register under registration number 119281.

1.3 CCLA Fund Managers Limited (CCLA FM) is a company registered in England and Wales with company number 8735639.It is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under FSMA and is entered on the Financial Services Register under registration number 611707.

1.4  The registered office of CCLA IM and CCLA FM is Senator House, 85 Queen Victoria Street, London, EC4V 4ET.You may also contact CCLA by emailing clientservices@ccla.co.uk.

2. Who may use this website

2.1 The information on this website is intended for investors and prospective investors in the CCLA Funds and or clients or prospective clients of CCLA's services. Only certain types of investor are eligible to invest in the CCLA Funds (in summary these are charities and local authorities and certain of the CCLA Funds are restricted to particular types of these investors).

  • Charities for these purposes are charities or charitable organisations registered with the Charity Commission of England and Wales, or charities exempt from registration, or other persons eligible to participate in collective investment schemes constituted under the Church Funds Investment Measure 1958, section 24 of the Charities Act 1993 (now amended to section 96 of the Charities Act 2011), or section 25 of the Charities Act 1993 (now amended to 100 of the Charities Act 2011), or equivalent organisations in Scotland or Northern Ireland.
  • Local authorities for these purposes are local authorities as defined in section 23 of the Local Government Act 2003.

2.2 Please ensure that you understand whether or not you are an eligible investor in respect of the CCLA Funds, investments and investment services referred to on this website.

3. The purpose of this website

3.1 This website is for information purposes only and is intended as a general introduction to CCLA and the Funds it manages and/or provides investment management services to. The website content and any products and/or services described within it are subject to change without notice.

3.2 Nothing contained on this website constitutes the provision of investment, tax, legal or other advice. This website should not be regarded as constituting a distribution or an offer or solicitation to sell shares or units in any of the funds managed by CCLA outside the UK. Any opinions expressed on individual funds, services or products represent our views at the time of preparation and should not be interpreted as a personal recommendation to buy or sell any of the investments that may be referred to.

3.3 In using this website you may navigate between different pages which relate to different Funds. Each webpage will clearly identify the Fund to which it relates and bespoke information presented on each webpage will relate to the identified Fund.

4. Risk warning

4.1 The value of the CCLA Funds’ units and/or shares and the income from them can fall as well as rise and an investor may not get back the amount originally invested. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns.

4.2 Please refer to the Funds’ individual scheme particulars or prospectus for an overview of the investment risks identified by CCLA and the applicable terms and conditions for investing in the Funds, including rules concerning when sums invested may be realised by the investor. Any estimates of future capital or income returns or details of past performance on this website are for information purposes and are not to be relied on as a guide to future performance.

4.3 Persons who do not have professional experience in matters relating to investments are strongly encouraged to consult with a financial adviser before making any investment decision.

5. Complaints and compensation

8.1  All complaints will be handled in accordance with CCLA’s Complaints Policy  which can be found at https://www.ccla.co.uk/helpful-links/ccla-complaints-policy.

 If either CCLA IM or CCLA FM cannot meet its obligations (for example, where it has stopped trading and there are insufficient assets to meet its obligations), investors may be eligible to claim compensation up to a maximum of £85,000 from the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. There are limits on who is eligible to claim and which funds are covered. For further information about the Financial Services Compensation Scheme please refer to www.fscs.org.uk or phone 0800 678 1100.

6. CCLA's liability

6.1 We give no warranty or representation and accept no liability for the accuracy, completeness or appropriateness of the information and material available on this website. Your use of any information or materials is entirely at your own risk and we accept no liability for any damage or loss including loss of profit whether direct, indirect or consequential in respect of the use of this website or its content; however, we do not exclude or restrict any liability that we may have under FSMA.

6.2 Due to the nature of the Internet, errors, interruptions and delays may occur at any time. Accordingly, this website is provided on an "AS IS" and "AS AVAILABLE" basis without any warranties of any kind. We shall have no liability, contingent or otherwise, or any responsibility whatsoever, for any interruption in availability of this website regardless of whether the connection or communication service is provided by CCLA or a third party service provider.

6.3 Transmission of information via the Internet is not completely secure and we cannot guarantee the security of your data transmitted to this website. Any transmission is at your own risk. We will use strict procedures and security features to try to prevent unauthorised access and we will do our best to protect your information (including personal data). However, we accept no liability in the unlikely event of a breach of our secure computer servers.

6.4 We will use reasonable endeavours to ensure that this website does not contain or promulgate any viruses or other malicious code. However, it is recommended that you should virus check all materials downloaded from this website. We will not be liable for any viruses, code, files or programs designed to interrupt, restrict, destroy or otherwise compromise the integrity of the website or any hardware on which it is hosted. We exclude to the fullest extent permitted by applicable laws all liability in connection with any damage or loss caused by computer viruses or other malicious code originating or contracted from this website.

7. Third party websites

7.1 This website may provide links to certain websites sponsored and maintained by third parties. CCLA is not responsible for the accuracy of information contained within websites provided by third parties and makes no representations concerning the content of such third party websites. The fact that CCLA may provide a link to another website does not constitute an endorsement, authorisation, sponsorship, or affiliation by CCLA with respect to that website, its owners, or its providers. You will be responsible for complying with the terms and conditions of use for any linked website.

8. Copyright and trade marks

8.1 CCLA is the owner or the licensee of all intellectual property rights in this website, and in the material published on it. Those works are protected by copyright laws and treaties around the world. All such rights are reserved.

8.2 You must not use any part of the materials on this website for commercial purposes without obtaining a licence to do so from us or our licensors.

8.3 No use of CCLA's name, logos and/or other trademarks (whether registered or unregistered) may be made by you without separate express written agreement being given by us, which shall be at our sole discretion.

9. Data protection

9.1 We will hold any personal information that you may provide to us through our CCLA website in confidence and in accordance with CCLA’s Privacy Notice and current Data Protection Legislation. CCLA is the data controller of any such information for these purposes.

9.2 You agree that the CCLA may process your personal data to: (i) confirm your identity and carry out background checks (which may involve sharing your personal data with third parties such as credit reference agencies); (ii) provide our services to you; (iii) follow up with you after you request information; (iv) comply with any requirement of any applicable statute, regulation, Financial Conduct Authority Rule and good practice and to fulfil our obligations under any reporting agreement entered into with any tax authority or revenue service(s); (v) prevent and detect abuse of our services or any of our rights and to protect our (and others’) property and rights; (vi) contact you by post, e-mail or telephone to bring to your attention additional products or services which may be of interest to you (you may inform CCLA at any time if you do not want to receive such communications); and (vii) as otherwise agreed by you. Failure to provide the personal data requested (or to agree to the above or below uses) may mean that CCLA is unable to provide the services requested.

9.3 CCLA may pass your personal data to any other firm within CCLA but will not pass on any personal data to any other third party except: (i) where, in relation to the performance of its services to you, CCLA sub-contracts part of the services or any support services; (ii) as agreed by you; or (iii) where required to do so for regulatory purposes as set out above.

9.4 CCLA may in exceptional circumstances transmit and process your personal data outside of the UK  in countries that do not provide the same level of data protection as the UK. In such unusual circumstances, you agree that it may do so subject to CCLA endeavouring to ensure that the arrangements comply with the standards required by the UK Information Commissioner.

9.5 Your use of this website (and your interest in particular webpages or particular CCLA products or services) may be monitored by CCLA. CCLA may keep records of all business transactions for at least five years.

9.6 By accepting these Terms of Use, you agree to the processing and disclosure of personal information as above. You are entitled to request details of information we may hold about you and to require us to correct any inaccuracies in your personal data. CCLA will treat all clients' records as confidential and so reserve the right to provide copies of your particular record, rather than allow access to files which may contain information about other clients. If you wish to access copies of your personal data or ask about the above arrangements, please contact CCLA's Data Protection Adviser at CCLA Investment Management Limited, Senator House, 85 Queen Victoria Street, London, EC4V 4ET.

9.7 Full details of CCLA’s Privacy Notice is available on CCLA’s website. Full details of CCLA’s Data Protection Policy, are available on request.

10. Cookies

10.1 This website uses cookies to distinguish you from other users of the website. This helps us to provide you with a good experience when you browse the website and also allows us to improve the website.

10.2 When you confirm you have read this page we will place a cookie on your computer to recognise you and prevent this page reappearing should you access this website on future occasions. The cookie will expire after six months, or sooner should there be a change to this important information.

10.3 You can activate the setting on your Internet browser to refuse the setting of all or some cookies. However, if you use your Internet browser settings to block all cookies (including essential cookies) you may not be able to access all or parts of the website. To help us provide a more personalised viewing experience we recommend that you view this website with a JavaScript enabled browser.

10.4 For more information about cookies, including how to set your Internet browser to reject cookies, please visit www.allaboutcookies.org.

11. Recording of communications

 Your telephone calls and electronic communications with CCLA may be recorded. You agree that CCLA may deliver copies or transcripts of such recording to any court or competent regulatory authority.  Such records of conversation and/or communications with you will be available on request for a period of five years (or, where requested by the FCA, for a period of up to seven years) from the date when a record is made.

12. General

12.1 Each of the paragraphs of these Terms of Use operates separately. If any court or relevant authority decides that any of them are unlawful or unenforceable, the remaining paragraphs will remain in full force and effect.

12.2 If we fail to insist that you perform any of your obligations under these Terms of Use, or if we do not enforce our rights against you, or if we delay in doing so, that will not mean that we have waived our rights against you and will not mean that you do not have to comply with those obligations.

12.3 These Terms of Use are governed by English law and are available only in English. You and we both agree that the courts of England and Wales will have non-exclusive jurisdiction over any dispute or claim (including non-contractual disputes or claims) arising out of or in connection with these Terms of Use.

18 August 2021             

 

 

 

Public sector funds

Public sector funds

The Local Authorities Property Fund (“LAPF” or “the fund”) is an unregulated collective investment scheme. As such, only persons who have been assessed as elective professional clients by CCLA in respect of the fund (or are already investors in the fund) are able to access details of the fund on this website.

If you have not been assessed as an elective professional client by CCLA or are not an existing investor in the fund, please contact us to discuss this fund:

Client Services

clientservices@ccla.co.uk

0800 022 3505

I confirm that I am a local authority/public sector body as defined in section 23 of the Local Government Act 2003. I also confirm that I have been assessed as an elective professional client by CCLA and/or I am an existing investor in the LAPF.